The latest episode of Threshold has been posted on my Patreon for Threshold patrons! In this episode, the crew spends the day at the feast of Bounty’s Blessing. In addition, young Tari meets the Silver Flame missionary Epitaph, pictured above; Epitaph and this art will be seen in the upcoming Frontiers of Eberron!
In the meantime: Each month, I ask my Patreon patrons to submit questions. Sometimes these form the basis of articles, but there’s often questions that are interesting but have short answers. As I’m getting read to do a new call for questions, I wanted to post a lightning round with some of the questions patrons asked in May.
Do the Overlords, and their envoys in the Lords of Dust, have any form of a non-aggression pact towards one another, or is it just a free-for-all should the machinations of one come into conflict with another?
This is addressed in this article. A critical line: “The Overlords weren’t allies and had no interest in cooperation. When the domains of two overlords overlapped they would clash, and many took great joy in these conflicts.”
To begin with, don’t just think of the overlords as powerful rakshasa. They engage with reality on a fundamentally different level than their lesser minions. Overlords are primordial forces that shape reality around them sheerly by existing. In a real way, you can think of overlords as kaiju, like Kong or Godzilla. Mortal lives and cities are utterly insignificant to them and they will sweep them aside without even noticing. Rak Tulkhesh spreads rage and war. He doesn’t meticulously plan out the details of these actions because he doesn’t have to; if he is unleashed in his full power, everyone within his sphere of influence will be consumed by bloodlust and a hunger for conflict. Now, with this in mind, one can ask: could Kong and Godzilla have a non-aggression pact? Well, they certainly might team up in a particular encounter in order to defeat Monster Zero. But it’s not like they’re WRITING SOMETHING DOWN. and the next time they meet, Kong might decide to kick Godzilla’s @$$.
However, THE LORDS OF DUST are a completely different story. They are servants of the overlords and seek to return reality to a state of primordial chaos, but THEY engage with the world on a far smaller scale. Rak Tulkhesh will just sweep over a nation and cause it to collapse into savage warfare, because that’s the power he wields. But MORDAKHESH doesn’t have that power, and HE has to manipulate newspapers and subvert generals and make long term plans. And with that in mind, the PURPOSE of the Lords of Dust and the Bleak Council of Ashtakala IS to facilitate cooperation and communication between the servants of the different overlords in order to prevent unnecessary conflicts. So if Mordakhesh and Hektula find that they both have plans for a particular group of adventurers, they will meet in Ashtakala and try to work something out. And in general, they do manage to avoid unnecessary conflict with one another. But the key word there is “unnecessary”; they will almost always put the interests of their overlord ahead of the interests of the Lords of Dust as a whole… which is a weakness that can potentially be exploited.
How does public education actually work in Khorvaire? Who receives free education? Is it any different in, say, Sharn, particularly the lower wards?
The educational system of the Five Nations is described on page 132 of the Eberron Campaign Setting: “Throughout the Five Nations (or at least what’s left of them), formal schooling is considered a right and a necessary part of every child’s training. Rural manors maintain schools for the sons and daughters of the peasants and laborers. Private tutors provide an education for the children of royal and economic nobility. In towns and cities, schools cater to all who wish to attend. In no case is education mandatory; however, most people understand the advantages offered to them by the remnants of the Galifar education system. Higher education and study is available at a number of colleges and universities, as well as among the religious institutions.” So while they’ve never been specifically mentioned, we can assume that there are public schools in Sharn. With that said, I think it’s reasonable to assume that this system faces the challenges of any public schooling system, and that there are regions — such as the lower wards of Sharn — where schools will be understaffed and underfunded. It’s also important to note that the ECS specifies that education is offered but never mandatory. Nonetheless, the Five Nations do have a reasonably effective public education system… which is why it’s taken for granted that the average person in the Five Nations speaks Common and is literate.
How does Morgrave university works in terms of recruiting new students? How much it can cost per year? Or is it the talent that forms entry barrier, not the money – can they have some sort of research for especially talented young people and offer them free tuition? For example, is it possible that some people from Morgrave notice poor urchin kid on the street and take him in because he is a talented sorcerer and seems like promising/useful student and/or magic user?
Here’s a relevant comment from Wayfinder’s Guide to Eberron:
As a Morgrave student, you’re not an adventurer yet. You’ve got talent, but you’re learning. Consider how your background ties into this. As a noble, are you an entitled rich kid who thinks you’re better than everyone else? As an urchin, did you somehow earn a scholarship, or are you literally sneaking into your classes? As a criminal, you could be the daughter of a Boromar crime boss, or you might be an entrepreneur selling dreamlily to the nobles. A charlatan could be a brilliant drama student or an undercover spy trying to root out enemy agents in the faculty. If you’re an entertainer you might be a prodigy whose talent is only just emerging. A Morgrave story is about coming of age and unlocking your potential. So think about your background as a way to set up the person you’re becoming, as opposed to representing adventures that you’ve already had.
The point here is that I would make the price the price of plot. D&D economics are extremely nebulous, in order to calculate a REALISTIC tuition I’d have to sit down and concretely establish the actual incomes of the different social classes of Khorvaire, which frankly I don’t have the time to do. Hence the suggestion to use backgrounds above. If you want the characters to be students at Morgrave, then they ARE students at Morgrave. If a character’s a noble, then their family is paying their tuition. If they’re an urchin, either they have a scholarship or they are sneaking into classes. The point is, the character is going to Morgrave; I’ll use their story to decide exactly how.
The only time I would want to set a concrete tuition was if it was an important plot point that the character has to RAISE that tuition over the course of their adventures, following the model of The Name of the Wind — but note that in the Kingkiller Chronicles, THE TUITION IS DIFFERENT FOR EVERYONE, which again allows the author to set the tuition at the rate that makes it most interesting for the story. 10 gp could be an insurmountable obstacle to a 1st level character and completely trivial for a 4th level character; so a system that bases the tuition off of what you want it to be for THIS story is going to be more useful than me arbitrarily setting a cost that could be too high or too low for the story you want to tell.
What are the towns inside the Towering Wood like? We know about Greenheart and the feyspire Shae Loralyndar, but are there others? Who lives there, and how are they different than the ones in the western Reaches?
There are very few traditional “towns” in the Towering Wood; the 3.5 ECS notes that “In the great wood, the druid sects and shifters typically live in small communities that are roughly equivalent to thorps and hamlets.” Essentially, these are communities that will be tied around an extended family and live off the land; whenever population grows to a level that strains local resources, a group will split off and start a new home in unclaimed territory. The Towering Woods are vast and population density is extremely low, so there’s no shortage of space. Towering communities employ primal techniques instead of arcane or mundane industry, so you will often find homes that are embedded into living trees or that are made of stone that has been shaped by hand. Envoys—often druidic initiates—travel between family estates, sharing news and needed supplies. Shae Loralyndar is an unusual exception, and there are a handful of satellite elven/Greensinger villages around it, but those represent a distinct culture that’s different from the mainstream—just as there are nomadic shifter tribes that have traditions that are entirely different from the settled folk.
What does prophetic significance look like? Is dragonmark graffiti’d on the wall of a ruined building prophetically significant? How do the Chamber and Lords of Dust recognize this significance?
This could definitely be the subject of a longer article, but in brief: what’s been said about the Prophecy is that it takes many forms and involves more than one element at a time. IE it can be crop circles; fissures formed by an earthquake; graffiti on a wall; an unusual pattern of bloodstains. But this is COMBINED with a particular planar or lunar conjunction, a spike in magical energies, the presence of three dragonmarked people, etc. This is part of why it’s generally only creatures with vast lifespans and enormous resources that are able to interpret it. That graffiti on the wall MIGHT be significant, but unless you’ve been studying the Prophecy for a thousand years (or you’re, say, a cleric of the Prophecy with divine insight) you don’t have the context to fully interpret it.
Can Aberrant Dragonmarks appear on Warforged?
Yes. It’s an extremely bizarre thing that will be seen as a curiosity and draw interest from certain scholars, but it is possible.
That’s all for now! Thanks again for my Patreon supporters for asking interesting questions and for making these articles possible.
Makes me wonder about the Eldeen Reaches right now. First of all, there a frontier nation. Aundair is not, and Aundair would like the territory back in it’s possession. Sounds like a good place to start a campaign, like Threshold. There’s a lot of potential in the Eldeen Reaches.
I’m certainly rooting (heh) for a Frontiers of Eberron: EldeenTown
Frontiers of Eberron: Thaliost
Subtitle: Before the Eldeen
Subsubtitle: Give us our stuff back
The Eldeen Reaches will play a slight role in FRAG, as Sylbaran and Silver Lake are part of the western frontier. But I do have plans to delve more deeply into the Eldeen in the future.
Do schools in the Five Nations include changelings, shifters and goblins in their student body? Or are they mostly taught in their own communities? If there are kalashtar children in Khorvaire I’d imagine they mostly just blend into human classrooms, but Overlook might have enough of them to be included in the question too?
Do schools in the Five Nations include changelings, shifters and goblins in their student body?
Sure! Any citizen is entitled to education. In a place where you have a particular density of a species—like the changelings of Dragoneyes—what’s possible is that you’ll see a local school with a majority of that species; there might be a public school in Dragoneyes that teaches the core curriculum of Galifar, but also has a secondary curriculum taught by changelings for changelings. But overall, the public schools of the Five Nations are open to any citizen of the nation, and you could find a dwarf, a goblin, a shifter, and potentially even an immigrant ogre all sharing a classroom. This does reflect the fact that none of these species have monocultures. A changeling who’s part of the Children of Jes won’t stay in one place long enough to go to school, while a Passer changeling will go to school but you’ll never know they’re a changeling. But stable changelings like those in Dragoneyes can certainly attend public schools if they wish.
Eeeey, my question regarding Overlords came up. Good to know that the potential Rak Tulkhesh vs Daughter of Khyber clash may in fact be able to be a thing if the PCs pull the right strings in my campaign…
Oh, definitely. The Daughter of Khyber definitely puts her own interests ahead of those of the other overlords, while Rak Tulkhesh is never going to back down from a fight…
Speaking of the nature of the Overlords, I always wondered how to handle partial releases of overlords and reconcile that with their actions and motives. Ram Tulkhesh is the embodiment of the Rage of War, would its avatar in a partial release actively work towards further freedom, or merely embody its nature. Effectively, how much creative thought is allowed in a being that embodies a pure concept of evil?
Effectively, how much creative thought is allowed in a being that embodies a pure concept of evil?
It definitely depends on the entity. Sul Khatesh and Bel Shalor both reflect concepts of evil that have room for scheming and subtlety. Rak Tulkhesh, as a rule, is NOT especially subtle and might just start the biggest fight he can. I think that for many of the Overlords, their SPEAKERS—their chief lieutenants in the Lords of Dust—are actually more likely to scheme on their behalf. Essentially, when it comes to Rak Tulkhesh, I think it’s quite likely that MORDAKHESH is the one who’s making the clever plots and buying newspapers, while the Rage of War itself is a more primordial FORCE. But really, there’s no wrong answer here.
To try to make an analogy: interpreting the Draconic Prophecy would be like seeing a 日 (nichi, or ‘day’)-shaped cloud in the sky one day, then having the context to know that a particular surge in Fernian and Irian energies in the same month means the 日 is part of 日用品 (nichiyouin, or ‘daily necessities’).
For tuition costs, saying it’s about 1 or 2 d4*10 (25 to 50GP) for full wizard schooling would explain why Wizards in 3.5 had less starting gold (beyond the game mechanics of their class not mandating anything but an inexpensive component pouch while others need big weapon/armor/instrument/tools).
Wizard: It’s so expensive to buy all these textbooks!
Warlock: I wouldn’t know, I got mine from my Patron.
Sorcerer: There are textbooks?
Imagine the elven professor who has taught the same Early Galifar History syllabus verbatim for the past three centuries…
Lots of enlightenment here! Your comment about basic education being free to any citizen of the Five Nations stimulated a question. In the capitals of the Five Nations (and maybe other major cities like Sharn) are there schools for the children of diplomats? Would each nation/embassy handle their own, or would they pool resources? I find the notion of a school for diplomat’s kids with a mixed bag of Zil, Dar, Aereni, Mror, etc. youngsters to be an amusing concept. You could even get a plot hook for an adventure echoing the Hardy Boys/Nancy Drew where one of the kids gets kidnapped (for ransom, or leverage over the ambassadorial parent) and the other kids in their class decide to pool their talents and stage a search and rescue on their own.
Are there rakshasa or Prakhutu that refuse to cooperate with the lord of dust and do their own thing? Possibly going full renegade to counter the lords of dust?
Remember that fiends aren’t mortal creatures. They’re incarnate ideas, spawned to fill a particular purpose and brought into existence with the knowledge and abilities they need to perform that function. In the case of rakshasa, they didn’t choose to serve their overlord to begin with; they were literally SPAWNED IN THE HEART of their overlord. In a very real sense, they are PART of their overlord. So for most fiends, it is simply impossible for them to even conceive of turning against their overlord; their loyalty is embedded into every fiber of their being.
Having said that: this is how things are supposed to work. But systems can fail. Out of tens of thousands of quori, 67 split to form the kalashtar. We’ve never said how many radiant idols exist—I’d say less than 67—but some do exist. In both cases we’re dealing with immortals created for a purpose who have mutated away from that purpose. So it is possible that a rakshasa could turn against its overlord or the Lords of Dust. With that said, when an immortal is killed, it is reborn in its overlord’s heart demiplane. Just as the quori seek to destroy the kalashtar so their spirits can be “reset”, I would expect that if a rebellious rakshasa was destroyed it would be reset to its “proper” outlook when it was reborn… and that all loyal servants of the overlord would do their best to expedite the process. So a rebel rakshasa would need to be VERY careful and wouldn’t have the full benefits of immortality; they wouldn’t age, but if they were killed, their identity would be lost.
So, anything is POSSIBLE if you want it to be possible. But not something I’m personally interested in pursuing. The kalashtar already tell the story of “rebel fiends” and the shulassakar and lingering couatl provide a source of ancient celestials that can aid adventurers, and the Lords of Dust are already a fairly unstable alliance; I don’t personally feel a need to through rebel rakshasa into the mix. If I did, I’d likely do it in the form of a single immortal hermit who’s maintaining a deep, deep cover to avoid being destroyed by the Lords of Dust—a potentially interesting source of information, but someone who can’t afford to draw too much attention or they’ll be destroyed.
Can aberrant dragonmarks appear on kalashtar, and if so, what sort of effect does the dragonmark have upon the quori spirit?
On the point of eligibility for basic education, one gets the distinct sense that a lot of things in Galifaran law technically accrue only to citizens, but likely in many places that has tended to be interpreted to include residents. So a school down in Khyber’s Gate is probably not that concerned how many of its students are technically citizens and how many are from the families of droaamite immigrants; they’ve got bigger concerns (like whether they’ll even have enough books for the class to share), and most folks down there probably don’t have papers either way. On the other hand, there might be some places where things are interpreted more strictly.